Leonardo's Mona Lisa (1503-1519): The Painting Leonardo Carried With Him for Sixteen Years
Leonardo da Vinci (1452-1519) began work on the painting now called the Mona Lisa in approximately 1503 in his Florence workshop — he was fifty-one years old at the time, had recently returned to Florence after the 1499 fall of his Milanese patron Ludovico Sforza, and was beginning what would become the second major Florence period of his working life. The 77 × 53 centimetre painting on poplar-wood panel (oil paint applied in multiple thin sfumato glazes over an underpainted tempera ground) shows a half-length portrait of a young woman seated in three-quarter profile against a mountainous background landscape, her hands folded one over the other on the arm of her chair, her gaze directly engaging the viewer with a faint enigmatic half-smile. The sitter has been identified with very high confidence as Lisa Gherardini (1479-1542), the twenty-four-year-old wife of the Florentine silk merchant Francesco del Giocondo, based on the 2005 Heidelberg University rediscovery of a marginal note in a 1503 Florence copy of Cicero's letters specifically identifying "Leonardus Vincius pictor" as currently working on the portrait of "Madonna Lisa del Giocondo." Leonardo worked on the painting for approximately sixteen years across his subsequent moves from Florence to Milan (1506-13) to Rome (1513-16) to France (1516-19) — he carried the poplar panel with him through all four cities and never delivered the painting to its commissioning patron. The painting was in Leonardo's possession at his death in the French Loire-valley residence of Clos Lucé on the 2nd of May 1519 and passed to his apprentice and heir Gian Giacomo Caprotti da Oreno (Salaì); from Salaì it passed to the French king François I; from François I it entered the French royal collection, where it has been continuously since.
Lisa Gherardini, the 1503 commission, and the 16-year working period
Lisa Gherardini was twenty-four years old in 1503, three years married to Francesco del Giocondo (a Florentine silk merchant of moderate prosperity), with two surviving children (a son Piero and a daughter Camilla). She had given birth to a third child Andrea on the 12th of December 1502 — six months before Leonardo began the portrait — and the standard art-historical reading is that the portrait was commissioned by Francesco del Giocondo as a celebration of the family's third child and the move to a new larger house on Florence's Via della Stufa earlier in 1503. The commission was therefore conventional. Leonardo's failure to deliver was not. The standard reading is that Leonardo's slow working method (the sfumato glaze technique requires each glaze layer to dry completely before the next can be applied, which on a portrait of this scale produces a several-year base-completion time) combined with his 1506 move to Milan to work for the new French governor Charles d'Amboise (Leonardo took the panel with him) and his continuing experimental revisions to the composition across the next decade meant that the portrait was never finished to Leonardo's own satisfaction. The del Giocondo family did not receive the painting. Francesco died in 1538 (19 years after Leonardo) and his will makes no mention of the portrait; Lisa survived him by 4 years and died in 1542 at age 63. Neither saw the finished painting they had commissioned in 1503. The Mona Lisa is therefore the canonical example of a Renaissance commission that was never completed within its commissioning relationship.
Sfumato, the smile, and the technical contribution
Leonardo's specific contribution to Western painting in the Mona Lisa is sfumato — the Italian Renaissance technical term Leonardo himself used in his manuscript notes for the gradual blending of one tone or colour into another without any visible boundary line. The Mona Lisa's specific contribution to sfumato is the boundary-less transitions around the corners of the mouth and the corners of the eyes. The smile that has been continuously debated for five hundred years is technically a function of Leonardo's decision not to paint a hard boundary line between the lip and the surrounding facial flesh — the lip-edge is rendered in approximately twelve to fifteen separate sfumato glaze layers across a transition zone of approximately 4-5 millimetres on the painted surface. The effect is that the smile is not pinned to a specific facial expression but appears to shift depending on the viewing angle, the lighting, and the viewer's own attention. The 2010 Louvre conservation analysis confirmed the multi-layer construction: the corner-of-mouth transition zone contains approximately 30 distinct paint layers when imaged in cross-section. The smile is therefore the most-discussed single Western painted facial feature in the history of art-criticism — Vasari's 1550 Lives quotes Leonardo as saying he could make his subjects appear to be "smiling without smiling" — and the discussion is technically a discussion of sfumato glaze technique rather than of expression interpretation. The painting's specific compositional decision (the three-quarter profile, the directly-engaging gaze, the half-smile rendered in sfumato) became the canonical Western portrait composition that the next 500 years would return to repeatedly.
Why the painting matters now — and why it shouldn't matter as much as it does
The Mona Lisa is now the single most-recognised Western painted image worldwide. The painting's current Paris collection receives approximately 6.7 million annual visitors (2024 figure) and the painting itself is viewed by approximately 80% of those visitors, producing approximately 5.4 million annual physical viewings — the highest viewing rate of any single painted image in human history. The painting's global recognition is not a natural reflection of its quality. The painting was relatively obscure for most of its 1519-1911 history — held in the French royal collection across multiple regime changes, viewed by the limited 18th-and-19th-century French aristocratic public, considered by mid-19th-century art-historical writing as one of several major Leonardo paintings but not as the canonical Western masterpiece. The painting's elevation to global iconic status was a function of two specific 20th-century events. First: the 21 August 1911 theft. The Mona Lisa was stolen from the Paris collection by the Italian immigrant Vincenzo Peruggia, who had been working at the collection as a temporary glazier and hid the painting under his coat after the collection's Monday closure. The theft produced two years of international newspaper coverage (the painting was missing from August 1911 until December 1913 when Peruggia attempted to sell it to a Florence dealer) and made the Mona Lisa internationally famous for the first time. Second: the post-WWII mass-tourism era. The Paris collection's increasing accessibility to international tourists from 1945 onward concentrated viewing attention on the Mona Lisa as the must-see single object of the visit. The painting's contemporary visibility is therefore overdetermined — the visibility is a function of historical accidents (the 1911 theft, the post-1945 tourism flow) rather than of intrinsic art-historical quality. Many Leonardo scholars and art-historical writers have argued that the painting's elevated status displaces attention from other Leonardo paintings (the Last Supper, the Lady with an Ermine, the Saint John the Baptist) that may be of equal or higher artistic quality. The argument is broadly accepted within specialist art history but has had no measurable effect on the painting's global recognition.
Key takeaways
Leonardo da Vinci began the Mona Lisa in 1503 in Florence on a poplar-wood panel 77 × 53 cm. Sitter = Lisa Gherardini (1479-1542), 24-year-old wife of Florentine silk merchant Francesco del Giocondo. Sitter identity confirmed by 2005 Heidelberg University rediscovery of marginal note in a 1503 Florence copy of Cicero's letters identifying 'Leonardus Vincius pictor' as working on 'Madonna Lisa del Giocondo' portrait.
Leonardo worked on the painting for ~16 years across his moves Florence (1503-06) → Milan (1506-13) → Rome (1513-16) → France (1516-19). Never delivered to commissioning patron Francesco del Giocondo. In Leonardo's possession at his 2 May 1519 death in Clos Lucé Loire valley. Passed to apprentice Salaì → to French king François I → into French royal collection where painting has been continuously since.
Specific contribution to Western painting = sfumato (Leonardo's own Italian Renaissance term for gradual tone-blending without visible boundary lines). Corner-of-mouth transition zone contains ~30 distinct paint layers when imaged in cross-section (2010 Louvre conservation analysis). The famous half-smile is a function of sfumato glaze technique — the smile appears to shift depending on viewing angle, lighting, and viewer attention because no hard boundary line was painted between the lip and surrounding facial flesh.
Vasari 1550 Lives quotation: Leonardo could make his subjects appear to be 'smiling without smiling.' The phrase = canonical Vasari description of sfumato technique on facial features. Mona Lisa is the surviving Western canonical exhibit for the technique.
Painting's elevation to global iconic status was a function of two specific 20th-century events, not intrinsic art-historical quality: (1) 21 August 1911 theft by Italian immigrant Vincenzo Peruggia (Paris collection glazier who hid painting under coat after Monday closure) produced 2 years international newspaper coverage Aug 1911 - Dec 1913 when Peruggia attempted Florence dealer sale. (2) Post-1945 mass-tourism era concentrated viewing attention on the painting as must-see object.
Current Paris collection ~6.7 million annual visitors (2024 figure), painting viewed by ~80% = ~5.4 million annual physical viewings, highest viewing rate of any single painted image in human history. Many Leonardo scholars argue the painting's elevated status displaces attention from other equally-or-higher-quality Leonardo paintings (Last Supper, Lady with Ermine, Saint John the Baptist). Argument broadly accepted in specialist scholarship but has had no measurable effect on global recognition.
Browse Italian High Renaissance prints in the archive at zocineartdesign.etsy.com.
Comments